Sunday, November 25, 2007
Fear of the Unknown....
On one hand it was asserted that:
"John Key and the Nats do not have that level of credibility - basically no-one really knows what they plan to do or how much they are telling the public what they want to hear."
compared to:
"The Nats will probably die in the ‘national’ campaign from disappointments about the expectations they have already induced."
Now we all do it - get carried away with a line of argument which appears clear when we typed it, but, depsite sounding logical, actually falls down under analyisis, so I hope this critique is not seens as intended nastiness. It isn't.
What it indicates is the nervousness that can be stimulated by remaining an unknown quantity.
Looking also at a post here today by inventory2:
"I honestly believe that Labour don't quite know what to make of him, and the "not knowing" would make Helen feel decidedly uncomfortable (dare I say "not in control"??!!)- so maybe JK needs to keep them guessing for a bit longer!"
This brings me to the point about Key. is he setting himself to ride into Wellington on an ass with the crowds crying 'Hosannah!'?
Or will he end up on his ass with the crowds crying 'loser!' (excuse the stretched attempt at assonance.)
So, to address specifics:
National have floated some ideas and they went down like the proverbial Zeppelin. The fact that they floated them indicates a power-struggle within National. No right thinking potential PM would go with that kind of nonsense. So Key got jacked. pure and simple.
But it stretches credulity to suggest that the Nats seriously thought the public would go for it.
If they did they are evidently in the wrong trade.
So perhaps Key said 'fine, get it out of your system.' Perhaps now, they will listen to him.
Remember English got shot down by the divisive cabals within National. Perhaps Key and English share that common knowledge - the elite will stop at nothing to 'get you'.
What you have been witnessing is a very quiet power struggle from which Key will emerge victorious. The struggle has not been between Key and English, but by Key and English - to put the 'old-guard' of National in their place.
What is emerging is a democratised impulse in the Natinal higher ranks. This democratised leadership has only been compounded by the egregious (:0) EFB. Suddenly, Labour have, in their anxiety to sabotage National's battle-plan, begun to appear like the bad guys English and Key are starting to look like giant-killers.
Despite what Labour try to make of the Key English parnership, the fact is they are both 'local boys made good'. They share a common loathing of 'privilege' and both have historical rationales for why they should want to destroy priviledge and its trappings.
But above all, Key is keeping his hand well hidden. The Labour Party in government are trepidatious about launching policy too soon - it might be bettered by National. National feel they have no need to outline policy now, otherwise they would have done so.
Key is playing a very clever and confident game, by remaining silent.
Perhaos there is an attack strategy from Natiional waiting in the wings.
But Labour, until it knows what it is attacking, is on the back-foot.
However the waiting game will only work for so long. If the mind-games are to reap long-term benefits for National, National, and Key in particular, need to come out on the attack soon.
Before Christmas.
Saturday, November 24, 2007
Is John the Key?
And the million dollar answer is 'If enough people want it."
Then that begs the question 'Why would they want it?"
Looking at the situation as it stands, it is possible that Labour have become out of touch. However it does not follow that John Key is the only alternative to Helen Clark.
because there is nothing evidentially to suggest that National are any less out of touch than Labour are.
For example the idea of limited sales of SOEs - technically a viable concept, but evidently frightening to the voter who is scarred by memories of losing 'the family Silver' under Muldoon. (to quote my old man).
Kiwisaver, on the other hand was a positive and widely welcomed initiative.
Even when Labour introduced the EFB - a complete shambles of a Bill - the opposition failed to capitalise on it,
So it is evident that National are on the back foot. Not only because they have a paucity of modern, forward-thinking policies, but also because the electorate is still psychologically averse to National as the Labour alternative.
Then there is the albatross around National's neck - the 'Hollow Men' accusation.
The most sympathetic interpretation of the EB fiasco is that it was a strategic miscalculation. The least sympathetic is that it was an attmept to 'rort' the election.
Even though Labour have their own albatross - the Pledge Card fiasco - they appear hell-bent on pretending it was perfectly alright, and that the changes to the law under the EFB represents the lesser of the evils - ie it will stamp out National's 'rorting'.
Then there is the issue of leadership. Helen Clark is a leader as we all understand the term. This is the strongest suit that Labour has. The fact that she will not be around much longer (IMO) is frankly so frighteneing to the Labour Party and to New Zealanders that they have refused to countenance it. So the election will be fought on the polite fiction that Helen is here to stay.
In contrast, Key is yet to prove his leadership credentials. Sure he seems like a nice enough chap. But his credibility as a potential prime Minister is severely hampered by this 'nice' image.
coupled by a dearth of imaginative policies that can capture the imagination of the voter.
So as far as the voter is concerned, all is ok. Helen Clark is a safe pair of hands, and Key is a nice enough chap, but - well - not to be trusted.
As it stands, this perception is all John Key's fault. The job of the opposition is 'to oppose'. John Key has failed to do so with any traction. Helen Clark, on the other hand has merely to continue 'business as usual' to ensure her own survival. Agian this perception goes to the heart of what constitutes effective leasership.
Yje electorate is not stupid. It knows Hemen Clark has her faults. But it is waiting for a leafer with the balls to face her. Anything less is basically pointless. Nice guys really do come last.
I think at the moment the playing field is pretty level.
If I were to use a domestic analogy, Labour is the love-rat husband who the spouse with low-esteem will cling to for the sake of the kids. Key is the new guy on the block - the promise of a new beginning, but carries the doubt that he has the 'x-factor' to convince the wife to risk it all and leave.
Labour may rely on the 'It's better the devil you know' argument, National may suggest 'You can do better.'
Simpy, it is all about whether the kiwi electorate has the requisite courage and high enough self-esteem to trust its future to an unknown quantity.
Friday, November 23, 2007
Gunpowder Plot or Damp Squib?
DEMOCRACY UNDER THREAT
Protest March Victoria Square to Cathedral Square
Wednesday 28 November 12.30. March starts 1.00pm.
Organiser of the Auckland and Wellington marches
John Boscawen will speak.
Thus came the clarion call for more dissent of a polite kind from kiwiblog http://www.kiwiblog.co.nz/ on behalf of one John Boscowan ( I might have known where there was a march to be organised, a Cornishman would be in there somewhere).
Meanwhile no one is taking my paranoia that the EFB could be used to pervert election results, so I'll just have to wear the pointy hat.
I opined (there's that word again) that the marches need to get more 'media-savvy' and start to burn effigies of Helen and (now I add, with a rum and Sprite inside me) the odd flag.
Point is the left could give lessons on this kind of thing and the polite display of faint approbrium at the EFB so far exhibited, isn't going to make any headlines.
My quote of the day comes from another kiwiblog poster (gd) who said:
http://www.kiwiblog.co.nz/2007/11/the_law_of_common_sense.html#comment-371517
"IV2 Lee C Pascal I have been posting here an elsewhere for some time now that the concepts of Left and Right are old outdated 20th century ideas.
the 21st century is now about freedom v control.
I call it the Max/ Min concept"
Back to me: But I think there is a crisis in the 'left':
I think that the crisis is a result of the adherence to the 'Third Way' philosophies of Giddens. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthony_Giddens
In particular the recent lack of consultation and open democracy prior to the formulation of the EFB suggests that:
In the age of late and reflexive modernity and post scarcity economy the political science is being transformed. Giddens notes that there is a possibility that "life politics" (the politics of self-actualisation) may become more visible than "emancipatory politics" (the politics of inequality); that new social movements may lead to more social change than political parties; and that the reflexive project of the self and changes in gender and sexual relations may lead the way, via the "democratisation of democracy", to a new era of Habermasian "dialogic democracy" in which differences are settled, and practices ordered, through discourse rather than violence or the commands of authority.[1]
The 'crisis' is that the left started out to go 'centrist' and allow market forces and social change to be administrated side by side, but, the magnetic attraction of capitalism, meant that the social agenda would always be compromised. The result - increasingly doctrinaire and authoritarian laws, to try and rectify the impulses of capitalism.
Back to square one.
Lee C Says: November 23rd, 2007 at 1:32 pm
Frank. spoken well. A Royal Commission of Enquiry should have been the first step, then public consultation then consultation with interested parties (Law Society) HRC and others, then a White Paper then a Draft Bill then a vote, then Select COomittee, then a vote.
I mean it isn’t rocket science, is it?
The fact that Labour have done it [the EFB] the way they have indicates an arrogance of breath-taking proprtions. But, as importantly indicates a strategic ‘void’ in their thinking, where they could have created a situation which would have enshrined them in the history books, and have in fact probably written their own epitaph.
I like to quote myself - it adds polish to my conversation. (Andy Capp said it first)
Finally on the Standard this superb article review was provided by:
"the sprout
Nov 23rd, 2007 at 8:00 pm
as long as National re-employ the Liberals’ strategists Crosby Textor, it’ll be race for sure.
http://www.pjreview.info/issues/docs/13_1/PJR13_1_7_hagerpp197-204.pdf"
This is an engaging account of the power struggle within National and how Brash became the 'nearly' man. It also refers to the powerful message of National Strategy prior to the last election. However it explains how Labour could have developed a strategy to marginalise and destroy the National Party's ability to fight an election. The most interesting thing I thought was that Brash was deposed from the inside of National because insider feared the direction that Brash was taking the party in the light of the EB involvement with the pamphlets.
Does this mean that National insiders sacrificed government for the sake of transparency?
Does it compound the loss that public knowledge of the EFB and Brash's deception probably lost them that valuable seat in Parliament?
If so the EFB must sound cruelly ironic.
I would love to see a similar breakdown of Labour's strategy at the same time.
Shooting from the hip I would suggest it is based around one central message. You can trust Labour to protect you from National.'
I can't wait to see what National's next strategy will be....
Thursday, November 22, 2007
It's All So Confusing
http://keepingstock.blogspot.com/
I started out yesterday looking at the discussion on kiwiblog about the EFB (I am not sure it it qualifies as an 'obsession' but heck, it sure is compelling stuff. No Right Turn has come out in support of David Farrer (relax, it isn't what you think):
http://norightturn.blogspot.com/2007/11/access-to-parliament.html
Within the debate I asked if the EFB is in danger of causing some kind of democratic meltdown should an incumbent Government challenge the legality of a contested seat.
No one answered. Because I ask stupid quesions? I don't expect to be understood in my own lifetime.... it is one prediction that becomes increasingly provable as I age, but still.
I asked because New Zealand has a real 'it sould never happen here' attitude, but I am sure the Americans had the same attitude right up until George Dubya Bush had Florida and the Presidency of the United States called in his favour by the Supreme Court. - see opening chapter of 'Dude, Where's My Country?' Where indeed?
The point being that confusion about the law is a bad thing. It encourages certain behaviours, when the object of the Law should be to protect us from certain behaviours.
John Marshall QC of the Law Society is requesting that the amended version go back to Select Committee. We all know that won;t happen. It is vital for some, that the Law is passed preferably before the New Year. 'Ooh! Just what I always wanted!'
The Herald is continuing its critique of the EFB and quotes Dr. Helena Catt of the Electoral Commission:
http://www.nzherald.co.nz/section/story.cfm?c_id=280&objectid=10477647
Also on Nine to Noon:
that’s our fear, that everywhere where we’ve got areas where interpretation isn’t clear that the parties will start using that as part of their attack on each other and that’s not going to do anything to encourage public interest in politics, trust in the election campaign.
I am interested in the complete acquiescence of the 'left' over the whole EFB issue. They appear hell-bent on defending this as some kind of evangelical angel of vengeance against the evils of 'big business' buying elections.
But I noted that even on Radio live 'The New voice of Talk Radio' Willy Jackson and John Tamihere are starting to talk about the EFB. and Willy suggested that the Unions had been curiously silent about the law.
In my view, if it walks like a duck and quacks like a duck, then it is highly probable that it is a duck. So when you have a large organisation in charge of millions of dollars and in collusion with our political masters, that is a blueprint for corruption. So what is the EPMU for example?
Don't get me wrong, I have a Union background and am sympathetic to Unions. But I have to query what is the diffrence between unions and big business when it comes to the seductive effect that wads of cash have on governments?
To my mind it is a sad reflection on the ideals of the left, that the EFB is illustrating that it is just like the right, only better-branded.
Speaking of the crisis of the left (well it's in the back of my mind)
Farrer did post this:
All Labour had to do was convene multi-party talks in late 2006 or early 2007 and seek agreement on some key issues. They would have been able to get them. They didn’t even try. Then they should have produced a Bill which just added on a few clauses to the Electoral Act, and it would have sailed through.
This does tie in with my growing sense that the - far from vindicating the charge that National is corrupt - rather indicates that this EFB thing is a mess of Labour's own making.
Is it the beginning of the end of 'The Third way'? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third_Way_(centrism)
Will Annette King come out fighting tomorrow? http://www.beehive.govt.nz/Biography.aspx?MinisterID=5
Was John Key really under one of those masks at the demonstration yesterday? http://www.thestandard.org.nz/
All this an more in our next thrillling instalment.
Wednesday, November 21, 2007
(Common) Sense and Sensibility
The Standard were rather cutting about it. http://www.thestandard.org.nz/?p=748#comments
Bevan Says: November 21st, 2007 at 3:37 pm
Isnt it ironic that the group campaigning to remove the anonymity from potitical donations, turns up to a counter protest march with their faces covered by masks?
In the meantime http://www.roymorgan.com/news/polls/2007/4247/ a new poll puts national 14 points ahead of Labour.
On The Standard:
insider
Nov 21st, 2007 at 10:02 am
Roy Morgan seems to have missed the debates on tax and the EFB for some issue that most would have supported the govt on
appears to be saying that the public will swing back to Labour - I think he is overly optimisitic. Then again, I am no psychic, and perhaps 'insider' is.
Most of the day was wrapped up in confusion (and that was just me) as people debated what would or would not be allowed under the new version of the EFB. I posted an opinion that the Labour Party and its supporter Parties have 'driven' people towards the National party so they have only themselves to blame.
As I posted this on 'The Standard' I shall go back and probably find my charred corpse still smoking, but wet from urine, dumped in a skip. They really are that violent on the left. (went back and found to my dismay that my opinions had been ignored.) So replace 'violent' with 'insensitive'.
Annette Kings plea for 'common sense' to interpret the EFB has been met with some derision. Even the hard out lefties have chosen to leave that one at the door, when they came in to debate today.
It will be interesting to see Annette King's progress after this. I sense it will be like watching a stricken B-52 fall out the sky, while we vainly watch for signs of a parachute.
virtualmark Says: November 21st, 2007 at 5:54 pm
Kimble, this is one of those areas where I’m a lot more sanguine about this bill than some. Personally I think:
* the Bill is poorly drafted and will not actually prove able to stop the behaviours it’s meant to stop* any attempt by Labour to see the Bill enforced will prove to be a PR disaster for them* the swing voters who’ll decide the next election are not Labour-acolytes and will be turned off by the attitudes this Bill encapsulates* the media attention on this Bill will tend to reinforce people’s general perception that Helen Clark is a cynical, mean-spirited, untrustworthy, died-in-the-wool politician who is only capable of self-interest* Labour will spend the entire electoral campaign defending themselves against this bill, making it all but impossible for them to get positive stories out into the media
I could go on, there’s other aspects of it that I think will backfire on Labour.
Overall it’s a sloppy piece of mis-guided & evil legislation that attacks our individual freedoms. But I think it’ll hurt Labour not help them, so for that reason I can’t get as wound up about it as some others.
In the meantime, the Greens are starting an offensive against Nationals' involvement with the Exclusive Brethren prior to the last election: http://www.scoop.co.nz/stories/PA0711/S00404.htm
Tuesday, November 20, 2007
This Time it's Personal
Of late, he has appeared to devote much energy to addressing issues raised by the Standard, when he posts on his own kiwiblog.
A proper little ding-dong of he-said/she-said has resulted.
Further to that, he has detected at least one 'Robert Owen' posting after his banning from kiwiblog back on kiwiblog as 'Santa Claws'. The ruse was (zzzz) ingeniously constructed so that 'Santa Claws' was 'outed on the Standard as DPF, but then denied it. Then he emerged on kiwiblog as a 'concerned right-winger', who posted his worries about the National Party, and John Key, in particular under the aegis of 'we will never win the election until we first clean up our act.'
I spotted him first. I called him as a 'sock-puppet', http://loupdargentonline.blogspot.com/2006/03/fwd-how-to-create-online-sock-puppet_23.html
DPF found him out today through checks on his URL. http://www.kiwiblog.co.nz/2007/11/hilarious_hypocrisy-2.html#comment-369968
In the meantime, the debate about the EFB rages on, and a second demonstration is planned for tomorrow in Wellington.
My prediction is that the EFB is going to leave a traile of Labour party politician's corpse in its wake. First Burton, next will be Annette King, will the third be Helen Clark? Time will tell.
Re the debate in Parliament, I leave you with dave from kiwiblog.
dave Says: November 20th, 2007 at 5:52 pm
And if you want to read what Annette King said in Parlament is herehttp://www.parliament.nz/en-NZ/PB/Debates/QOA/e/a/f/48HansQ_20071120_00000079-2-Electoral-Finance-Bill-Freedom-of-Expression.htm
A commentary is herehttp://big-news.blogspot.com/2007/11/lobby-groups-will-struggle-to-keep.html
Monday, November 19, 2007
What they've been saying about the EFB
Is the EFB is a pivotal moment in New Zealand's constitutional history?, and what have the other blogs, and other bloggers have been saying about it?
'Monkeys with Typewriters' was born as a result of an online ding-dong I was having with a poster called 'sonic' one day, in kiwiblog http://kiwiblog.co.nz/. it was about nothing in particular, but he remarked something along the lines of 'you can give a thousand monkeys typewriters and they will eventually produce Shakespeare, but that is more likely than me ever saying anything clever on a blog.'
This use of the monkey with typewriter imagery tickled me hugely. So here it is.
Needless to say, along with the knowledgeable and astute bloggers out there, it is the other 'monkeys with typewriters' on the other blogs that are the stars of this blog.
After the euphoria of debate around the Bill, in which the right accused the left of eroding democracy, the left retaliated by accusing the right of cow-towing to big business.
But also there is a worry about who will speak for the average kiwi? The National Party have shown such ineptitude over their handling of the oppositon to this Bill, and the Labour Party has gone to such extremes to maintain it as a 'beltway issue', that I feel that New Zealanders have been left out of the debate completely.
Apart from when the new Zealand Herald stepped in to slam the Bill. I wonder if they too will require some lind of regulation after this?
The consensus, perhaps may decide that 'democracy' is the main victim of the EFB, and not for the obvious reasons of its appalling drafting, either.
I'll be back later with some reports.
